The upcoming Beatles biopic has become a hot topic of conversation among fans and film enthusiasts alike. Directed by the acclaimed Sam Mendes, this ambitious project is set to hit theaters in April 2028 and promises to deliver a unique cinematic experience. Mendes revealed at CinemaCon this year that the biopic will be divided into four parts, with each film focusing on a different member of The Fab Four. He describes it as “the first binge-able theatrical experience,” a concept that has piqued the interest of audiences eager to delve deeper into the lives of these iconic musicians.
The casting choices for the biopic have generated significant buzz, with Paul Mescal taking on the role of Paul McCartney, Harris Dickinson portraying John Lennon, Barry Keoghan as Ringo Starr, and Joseph Quinn stepping into the shoes of George Harrison. This lineup has sparked a flurry of reactions from Beatles fans, many of whom have taken to social media to express their opinions. One particularly imaginative Redditor even proposed an “unhinged” fantasy casting, suggesting actress Maya Erskine could portray all four Beatles, drawing on her comedic chops from her role in the Hulu series “Pen15.”
This biopic marks a significant milestone, as it is the first time Apple Records, along with the two surviving members of the band, Paul McCartney and Ringo Starr, have granted the rights to their life stories for a film. With such a monumental responsibility, the pressure is on Mendes and his team to accurately and respectfully depict the lives and legacies of these legendary musicians.
However, the casting choices have not been without controversy. Some critics have pointed out that two of the actors, Barry Keoghan and Paul Mescal, are Irish, while the original band members hailed from Liverpool. Additionally, the A-list cast features actors who are older than the Beatles were at the time of their breakup, raising questions about authenticity. Social media has been abuzz with alternative casting suggestions, ranging from Jacob Elordi and Charlie Rowe to an all-female cast, showcasing the diverse opinions within the fan community.
In a cheeky twist, one Reddit user proposed a humorous alternative casting idea featuring Maya Erskine as all four Beatles. The post juxtaposed images of the Beatles with Erskine’s character from “Pen15,” highlighting her bowl-cut hairstyle and youthful demeanor. This playful suggestion resonated with many fans, with comments like “Hollywood quite simply wasn’t ready for this” and “And by unhinged you mean legitimate and correct,” indicating a level of enthusiasm for the unconventional idea.
As discussions about the biopic continue to unfold online, some fans speculate that the casting of such hunky actors may be a strategic move to generate buzz and excitement for the project. This theory is supported by the fact that the casting choices have certainly succeeded in capturing attention, with many fans expressing their mixed feelings about the current lineup. Comments like “Maya better than some of the main casting we got so far, why not?” and “I love everything about this and I wish it was true” reflect a desire for a more creative and inclusive approach to the casting process.
The anticipation surrounding this Beatles biopic is palpable, with fans eagerly awaiting more details as the release date approaches. As Mendes and his team work to bring the story of The Fab Four to the big screen, the conversation about who should portray these beloved icons will likely continue to evolve, showcasing the enduring legacy of The Beatles and their impact on music and culture.
