Martin Short’s Wedding Cake Mishap: A Hilarious Tale from Selena Gomez and Benny Blanco’s Big Day
In a delightful twist of events, comedian Martin Short recently recounted a wedding mishap that nearly turned Selena Gomez and Benny Blanco’s special day into a cake catastrophe. During an appearance on Jimmy Kimmel Live! on January 21, Short, 75, shared the amusing story of how he accidentally cut into the couple’s wedding cake before it was meant to be served, leaving everyone in stitches.
The Perfect Wedding
Selena Gomez, 33, and Benny Blanco, 37, exchanged vows in a picturesque ceremony in Santa Barbara, California, on September 27. The event was celebrated with a lavish reception where Short, alongside his Only Murders in the Building co-star Steve Martin, delivered a joint speech that added a touch of humor to the festivities. Short described the wedding as “perfect and beautiful,” setting the stage for what was meant to be a flawless evening.
The Cake Incident
As the night unfolded, the reception was organized in large tents, featuring cozy lounge-style seating areas. Short found himself seated with a lively group that included Martin and actor Paul Rudd. Amid the festivities, he spotted what he believed to be a small wedding cake near their section. As the evening progressed and the cake remained untouched, Martin mentioned he was preparing to leave, prompting Short to take matters into his own hands.
With a fork already in hand, Short insisted that Martin couldn’t leave without tasting the cake. In a moment of impulsive enthusiasm, he cut into the cake, slicing one side and then the other. It was only when the collective gasp of his friends echoed around him that he realized the gravity of his mistake. “Marty!” they screamed, and Short confirmed the shocking truth: “It was the wedding cake.”
The Aftermath
In a panic, Short attempted to salvage the situation with his fork, but the damage was done. “This was bad,” he recalled, noting that the incident occurred just an hour before the cake was to be presented to the couple. Turning to Rudd, he humorously suggested, “So, do we just leave?” The tension in the air was palpable, but Short’s comedic instincts kicked in, turning a potential disaster into a memorable anecdote.
A Quick Recovery
Realizing the need for immediate action, the wedding coordinator and chef were summoned to address the cake crisis. Short humorously reenacted the chef’s reaction, exclaiming, “What the hell happened here?” Fortunately, the skilled team quickly went to work, carefully repairing the cake and turning it slightly so it still appeared picture-perfect for the couple’s big moment.
A Memorable Evening
Despite the cake debacle, the wedding remained a joyous occasion filled with laughter and love. Short’s story not only highlights the unpredictable nature of wedding celebrations but also showcases the camaraderie and humor that can arise from unexpected situations. As the night continued, the guests were left with a hilarious tale that would undoubtedly be recounted for years to come, proving that sometimes, the best memories are born from the most chaotic moments.

