Episode 1: "You F###ed it, Friend."
In the premiere of Tell Me Lies, we are thrust into the emotional whirlwind of Lucy (Grace Van Patten) at Bree’s (Cat Missal) wedding in 2015. The atmosphere is charged with tension as Lucy grapples with her feelings for Stephen (Jackson White), a character whose shadow looms large over her life. When Pippa (Sonia Mena) inquires about Stephen, Lucy’s response reveals the complicated history between them, hinting at a past that has left scars on their friendships. Pippa’s vehement disdain for Stephen, who she claims ruined her life during their sophomore year, sets the stage for a season filled with intrigue and unresolved issues.
As the wedding unfolds, Bree confronts Lucy, accusing her of being a terrible person. This confrontation serves as a catalyst for the unfolding drama, revealing the fractures in their friendship. The narrative then shifts back to January 2009, where Lucy and Bree prepare to return to Baird College. The juxtaposition of their past and present highlights the cyclical nature of their relationships, particularly Lucy’s tumultuous connection with Stephen. Despite Bree’s reservations about Lucy rekindling her romance with Stephen, Lucy is optimistic, a sentiment that foreshadows impending disaster.
The episode introduces Evan (Branden Cook), who shares a complicated history with both Lucy and Stephen. Their interactions are laced with tension, particularly as Stephen’s careless nature is symbolized by the dirty dishes he leaves behind. This imagery reinforces the idea that Stephen creates chaos wherever he goes, a theme that resonates throughout the series.
As the characters navigate their complex relationships, Wrigley (Spencer House) grapples with the recent loss of his brother. Pippa’s concern for Wrigley adds depth to her character, showcasing her empathy amidst the chaos of college life. The episode captures the essence of youth—partying, experimenting with drugs, and the struggle for identity—culminating in a party where the characters indulge in MDMA. The consequences of their choices begin to unravel, setting the stage for conflict and emotional turmoil.
The episode culminates in a series of intimate moments between Lucy and Stephen, where their relationship is tested. Stephen’s manipulative tendencies surface as he tries to extract secrets from Lucy, showcasing his darker side. The tension escalates when Lucy wakes up to find Stephen gone, a harbinger of the emotional fallout to come.
Episode 2: "We Can’t Help It If We Are a Problem"
The second episode opens with Lucy’s anxiety about her relationship with Stephen, which is palpable as she tries to reach him. When he finally appears, the dynamic between them is fraught with tension. Their night out at a karaoke bar serves as a microcosm of their relationship—filled with isolation and misunderstandings. Stephen’s withdrawal from Lucy during the performance highlights his emotional unavailability, a recurring theme that complicates their connection.
Bree’s interactions with Amanda (Iris Apatow) introduce new layers to the narrative, as Bree grapples with her feelings for Oliver while trying to protect her friends from his predatory nature. The episode deftly explores themes of loyalty and betrayal, particularly as Lucy’s panic attack reveals the emotional toll of her tumultuous relationships. Pippa’s decision to procure drugs for Lucy underscores the lengths to which they will go to cope with their pain.
As the episode progresses, Stephen’s toxic behavior becomes more pronounced. His confrontation with Evan reveals the underlying tensions between the characters, particularly regarding their shared history with Lucy. The emotional stakes are raised as Stephen’s jealousy and anger threaten to unravel the fragile bonds between them.
The episode concludes with Lucy’s resolve to move on from Stephen, a declaration that feels both empowering and naïve. The cycle of heartbreak and betrayal continues, leaving viewers on edge as they anticipate the fallout from Lucy’s decisions.
Episode 3: "Repent"
In the third episode, Lucy awakens to a new reality—one without Stephen. This shift is marked by her interactions with Bree and Evan, who both serve as mirrors to her emotional state. The tension escalates as Lucy navigates her feelings of guilt and confusion, particularly after a night spent with Evan. The complexity of their relationships is further explored as Lucy grapples with her past choices and their implications for her future.
The episode delves into the theme of accountability as Lucy meets with her advisor about a study abroad program. This moment of potential growth is juxtaposed against her chaotic personal life, highlighting the struggle between ambition and emotional turmoil. Meanwhile, Bree’s burgeoning relationship with Alex, her former foster brother, adds a layer of complexity to her character, showcasing her desire for connection amidst the chaos.
Stephen’s descent into self-pity and anger is palpable as he interacts with Wrigley and the bartender, Max. His attempts to manipulate those around him reveal his deep-seated insecurities and the lengths he will go to maintain control. The tension between Stephen and Evan reaches a boiling point, illustrating the fractured friendships that define their college experience.
As the episode unfolds, Lucy’s attempts to move on are thwarted by her unresolved feelings for Stephen. The confrontation between them escalates, revealing the toxic dynamics that have come to define their relationship. Lucy’s desperate plea for Stephen to leave Bree out of their conflict underscores the emotional stakes at play, while Stephen’s threats reveal his manipulative nature.
The episode concludes with a shocking revelation—Diana’s pregnancy test—leaving viewers questioning the implications for all involved. This twist adds a layer of complexity to the already tangled web of relationships, setting the stage for further drama.
Review
The first three episodes of Tell Me Lies are a masterclass in emotional storytelling, filled with tension, betrayal, and the complexities of young adulthood. The characters are flawed yet relatable, navigating a world filled with poor choices and emotional upheaval. The interplay between Lucy, Stephen, Bree, and their friends creates a rich tapestry of relationships that keeps viewers engaged.
The show’s exploration of themes such as loyalty, betrayal, and the consequences of one’s actions resonates deeply, making it a compelling watch. The writing is sharp, and the performances are captivating, particularly from Grace Van Patten and Jackson White, whose chemistry is both electric and fraught with tension.
On a scale of tequila shots, the first three episodes earn a solid 4 Tequila Shot Award. Each episode builds upon the last, creating a sense of urgency and anticipation that leaves viewers eager for more. The chaos of college life, coupled with the characters’ emotional struggles, makes for a thrilling viewing experience that is both entertaining and thought-provoking.
