A Taste of Nostalgia: Vince Vaughn’s “Nonnas”
Vince Vaughn’s latest film, “Nonnas,” aspires to be a slice of cinematic comfort food, blending heartwarming storytelling with a nostalgic homage to Italian American culture. Streaming on Netflix, this film is based on the true story of Joe Scaravella, a New Yorker who opens a Staten Island restaurant featuring Italian grandmothers as chefs. With a cast that includes beloved veteran actors like Talia Shire, Lorraine Bracco, Brenda Vaccaro, and Susan Sarandon, “Nonnas” seems to have all the right ingredients for a delightful viewing experience.
A Familiar Recipe
Directed by Stephen Chbosky, who co-wrote the script with his wife Liz Maccie, “Nonnas” is crafted to evoke the warmth of family gatherings and the joy of shared meals. The film’s narrative is straightforward, with predictable story beats and a soundtrack that leans heavily on Italian American clichés. Yet, despite its lack of groundbreaking elements, the film is infused with a sense of earnestness and kindness that makes it hard to dismiss. In a world where kindness can feel scarce, the film’s simple message resonates.
The Heart of the Story
At its core, “Nonnas” revolves around Joe, a character who embodies the spirit of tribute to his late mother and grandmother. With no prior restaurant experience, Joe’s journey begins as a heartfelt endeavor to recreate the warmth he felt in their kitchens. Flashbacks to the 1960s depict a young Joe watching his family prepare Sunday sauce, capturing an idealized version of family life that feels almost commercialized in its perfection.
Cultural Homage and Missed Opportunities
While “Nonnas” pays homage to classic films like “Moonstruck” and “My Cousin Vinny,” it struggles to find a natural rhythm. The film oscillates between comedic moments and sincere reflections, often feeling disjointed. A significant misstep is the focus on Joe rather than the grandmothers, or “nonnas,” who are the heart of the story. Each woman has her own unique background—a former nun, a hair salon owner, a retiree, and a widow—yet their individual stories and culinary traditions are underexplored. Instead of bonding over food, the narrative leans into a makeover theme, missing the opportunity to delve deeper into the rich tapestry of their lives.
Vaughn’s Subdued Performance
Vince Vaughn delivers a commendable performance in a more subdued role, steering clear of the over-the-top comedic stereotypes that often accompany his characters. While a subplot involving a rekindled romance with his high school prom date feels somewhat tacked on, it adds another layer to the film’s overarching theme of second chances. The film avoids the pitfalls of gimmickry, allowing Vaughn’s character to shine through genuine moments of connection.
Cinematic Aesthetics
Chbosky and cinematographer Florian Ballhaus capture the essence of working-class Staten Island beautifully, presenting it without the gloss of over-romanticization. Even the “before” shots of the restaurant are imbued with a sense of potential, inviting viewers to share in Joe’s vision. The film’s visual storytelling complements its themes, drawing audiences into the world of the characters.
A Heartfelt Experience
“Nonnas” may not break new ground, but it serves its purpose as a comforting cinematic experience. Like a familiar dish, it offers a sense of safety and warmth, appealing to those seeking a feel-good story. With a runtime of 111 minutes and a PG rating for suggestive material, language, and thematic elements, “Nonnas” is a film that invites viewers to savor the simple joys of life, family, and the love that can be found in shared meals.
