The 2025 Critics’ Choice Awards brought together a dazzling array of stars, each vying for attention not just for their performances but also for their fashion choices. This year’s event was marked by a striking prevalence of black attire, unexpected misfires, and a few nods to past trends. While some celebrities dazzled on the red carpet, others left fashion enthusiasts scratching their heads in confusion.
A Patchwork Puzzle Gone Wrong
Joey King, known for her bold fashion choices, unfortunately stumbled with her Miu Miu dress. The ensemble resembled a last-minute art project, seemingly cobbled together from fabric scraps left over in the atelier. The awkward silhouette and messy execution resulted in a disappointing look that failed to showcase King’s usual sartorial prowess. Despite her ability to pull off daring styles, this particular outfit was a rare misstep that left many wondering what went wrong.
Elegant, but…
Kate Hudson graced the red carpet in a stunning black Thom Browne gown, undeniably beautiful yet lacking the excitement that fans have come to expect from her. While the gown was impeccably tailored, it felt somewhat muted compared to the vibrant hues Hudson often favors. The absence of a wow factor made this look feel more like a safe choice rather than a bold statement, leaving some to wish for a splash of color or an unexpected twist.
A Great Dress in Desperate Need of Glam
Kathryn Hahn made an entrance in a striking black strapless Oscar de la Renta Pre-Fall 2025 gown, complete with fabulous fringe detailing. While the dress itself was a winner, Hahn’s overall look fell flat due to a lack of glam. The gown deserved to be paired with more dramatic accessories or a bold beauty look to elevate it from merely good to truly spectacular. This was a missed opportunity for Hahn, who could have easily transformed the ensemble into a show-stopping moment.
A Sophisticated Return to Form
Maren Morris, nominated for her song "Kiss the Sky" from Wild Robot, showcased an effortlessly chic look in a black strapless Monique Lhuillier gown featuring an elegant ivory train. This choice marked a sophisticated departure from the over-the-top styles Morris previously favored, highlighting her growth as a fashion icon. The gown was not only flattering but also perfectly suited for a nominee, embodying elegance and grace without trying too hard.
A Floral Delight
In a sea of black, Marianne Jean-Baptiste stood out in a white Oscar de la Renta cape gown adorned with pink and green sequin floral appliques. This whimsical yet refined design was a breath of fresh air, showcasing Jean-Baptiste’s ability to embrace color and creativity. Styled by Jason Rembert, who had a stellar night dressing several other stars, Jean-Baptiste’s look was a delightful contrast to the darker tones dominating the event.
Wickedly Stylish in Silver
Marissa Bode, known for her role in Wicked, made a shimmering statement in a silver Maria Lucia Hohan gown. The dress featured the brand’s signature pleating and daring cut-outs, creating a sleek and elegant silhouette that exuded glamour. Bode’s choice was a perfect reflection of her rising star status, showcasing her ability to command attention on the red carpet while maintaining a sophisticated edge.
No
Rachel Brosnahan, a favorite on the red carpet, unfortunately fell victim to a dated Miu Miu design. While she often impresses with her fashion choices, this particular gown felt out of sync with her vibrant personality and style. The ensemble lacked the modern flair that Brosnahan typically embodies, making it a disappointing choice for the actress.
Spot the Difference
Sarah Michelle Gellar’s black Oscar de la Renta strapless gown with a rose motif sparked a sense of déjà vu among fashion watchers. The gown bore a striking resemblance to one previously worn by Priyanka Chopra, who donned a silver version at the Red Sea International Film Festival Closing Ceremony. Gellar styled her look with a Roger Vivier clutch, but the similarity in designs left some questioning the originality of her choice.
The 2025 Critics’ Choice Awards showcased a mix of fashion triumphs and missteps, with stars navigating the fine line between risk and reward. As the night unfolded, it became clear that while some celebrities embraced the opportunity to dazzle, others missed the mark, leaving fashion enthusiasts eager for the next red carpet event.
