The Critics Choice Awards: A Fashion Retrospective of Hits and Misses
Since its inception in 2014, the Critics Choice Awards has become a staple in the awards season calendar, attracting Hollywood’s biggest stars and showcasing their fashion choices on the red carpet. Much like other prestigious ceremonies such as The Golden Globes and The SAG Awards, the Critics Choice Awards has seen its fair share of stunning fashion moments alongside some notable missteps. This article delves into some of the most memorable fashion faux pas from the Critics Choice Awards, highlighting how even the most celebrated celebrities can sometimes miss the mark.
Natalie Portman’s Poncho Disaster
At the 2016 Critics Choice Awards, Natalie Portman was celebrated for her performance in "Jackie," winning the Best Actress award. However, her fashion choice that evening—a bright, floral-print poncho-like Alexander McQueen dress—left much to be desired. The shapeless mid-length dress overwhelmed Portman’s petite frame, giving the impression that she was drowning in fabric. Known for her elegant style, Portman’s choice was unexpected, especially considering the high stakes of the awards season. It was a stark departure from her usual methodical dressing, and one could hardly imagine Jackie Kennedy donning such an outfit.
Reese Witherspoon’s Ladies Who Lunch Look
Reese Witherspoon’s 2018 Critics Choice Awards ensemble—a black Prada dress—sparked confusion among fashion critics. While the dress itself was not inherently bad, it felt more suited for a casual brunch than a glamorous awards show. The above-the-knee length and sparkly crystals failed to elevate the look, making it appear somewhat plain and dowdy. Witherspoon is known for her chic style, and this outfit did not do justice to her vibrant personality. Despite the fashion misstep, her show "Big Little Lies" won Best Limited Series that night, providing a silver lining to her evening.
Bo Burnham Channels Batman’s Two-Face
The 2019 Critics Choice Awards saw Bo Burnham stepping onto the red carpet in a Thom Browne two-toned suit that evoked images of Batman’s Two-Face. While taking risks in fashion is commendable, Burnham’s ill-fitted suit, with pants that awkwardly stopped above his ankles, left much to be desired. The black and white contrast of the jacket was striking, but the overall execution fell flat. In a world where many men opt for safe choices, Burnham’s attempt at boldness was appreciated, yet it ultimately missed the mark.
Cynthia Erivo’s Over-Patterned Confection
Cynthia Erivo made a dramatic entrance at her first Critics Choice Awards as a nominee in a voluminous, mosaic-patterned Fendi gown. While the gown certainly turned heads, it was also a visual overload. The giant sleeves resembled inflatable devices, and the busy print was overwhelming. Erivo’s choice was undoubtedly daring, but it failed to deliver the stunning moment she and her team likely envisioned.
Emerald Fennell’s Pajama Day Look
The 2021 Critics Choice Awards were held virtually due to the pandemic, allowing stars to showcase their looks from the comfort of their homes. Emerald Fennell, nominated for "Promising Young Woman," opted for a bright pajama-like outfit that prioritized comfort over style. While loungewear has become a trend, the fluffy fake feathers on her sleeves and pant bottoms gave off a Vegas showgirl vibe that felt out of place for an awards show. The choice was a stark contrast to the glamorous looks that many other stars delivered that evening.
HoYeon Jung’s Statement Gown Falls Flat
At the 2022 Critics Choice Awards, "Squid Game" star HoYeon Jung aimed to make a bold statement with an art-deco-inspired Louis Vuitton gown. Unfortunately, the result was a drapey, boxy silhouette that did little to flatter her figure. The gown’s sculptural bottom half resembled a chandelier, and while the intricate embroidery was beautiful, it did not translate well to a red carpet moment. Jung’s attempt at high fashion became an unforgettable misstep.
Julia Garner Fizzles in Red
In 2023, Julia Garner made a bold choice with a bright red Ferragamo gown, but the outcome was less than stellar. The sheer high-low design created an unflattering silhouette, and at certain angles, it appeared unfinished. Garner, who has previously dazzled on the red carpet, fell short this time, with the gown failing to complement her natural beauty. The mismatched serpent-inspired jewelry further detracted from the overall look, although her makeup and slicked-back hairstyle were commendable.
Greta Gerwig’s Bag-Lady Fashion Fail
At the 2024 Critics Choice Awards, Greta Gerwig arrived in a white, baggy Molly Goddard gown that drew comparisons to being wrapped in an oversized bed sheet. The shapeless design did nothing to enhance her figure, and her neutral makeup and lack of accessories contributed to an overall bland appearance. Given the vibrant and playful nature of her film "Barbie," Gerwig’s choice felt particularly disappointing, as it missed the opportunity to reflect the film’s bold aesthetic.
The Critics Choice Awards continue to be a platform for both celebrated and controversial fashion choices. While the red carpet often showcases stunning ensembles, it also serves as a reminder that even the most fashionable celebrities can have off days. As the awards season progresses, fans and fashion enthusiasts alike will be eagerly watching to see what the stars will wear next, hoping for more hits than misses.
